TN English I
Logic Standards

site for teachers | PowerPoint show | Acrobat document | Word document | whiteboard resource | sound | video format | interactive lesson | a quiz | lesson plan | to print

Language | Communication | Writing | Research | Logic | Informational Text | Media | Literature

Language Arts Curriculum Standards 3001 - English I	Internet Resources
Checks for Understanding (Formative/Summative Assessment) 5.1 | 5.2 | 5.3 | 5.4 | 5.5 | 5.6 | 5.7 | 5.8 | 5.9 | 5.10 | 5.11 | 5.12
Describe the structure of a multi-faceted argument with a stated main claim or conclusion and explicit or implicit premises. 3001.5.1
Identify the elements of deductive and inductive arguments. 3001.5.2	Deductive vs Inductive Reasoning - [16 slides] examples of each type of reasoning with opportunities to practice Formal Versus Informal Logic - Deductive Versus Inductive Forms of Reasoning - [13 slides] somewhat advanced, good explanation of each type of reasoning House and Holmes: A Guide to Deductive and Inductive Reasoning - Lesson plan to designed distinguish between deductive and inductive arguments, and to have students construct and analyze deductive arguments and produce and evaluate inductive arguments - links to several attachments provided Inductive and Deductive Reasoning - short explanation followed by a worksheet to print, page 4 has the answers to this worksheet Inductive and Deductive Reasoning - [15 slides] designed for a math class but provides a good overlap of information for this standard Logic and Deductive and Inductive Reasoning - short article explaining the difference and giving examples of each Mission Critical: Induction vs Deduction - explanation followed by statements to evaluate, answers are provided Thinking About a Change? - explore deductive and inductive research, consider which method you use to formulate your opinions about the world.
Identify the roles premises play in developing deductive and inductive arguments. 3001.5.3	Aesop's Fables: Unity - lesson plan Deductive vs Inductive Reasoning - [16 slides] examples of each type of reasoning with opportunities to practice Formal Versus Informal Logic - Deductive Versus Inductive Forms of Reasoning - [13 slides] somewhat advanced, good explanation of each type of reasoning House and Holmes: A Guide to Deductive and Inductive Reasoning - Lesson plan to designed distinguish between deductive and inductive arguments, and to have students construct and analyze deductive arguments and produce and evaluate inductive arguments - links to several attachments provided Inductive and Deductive Reasoning - short explanation followed by a worksheet to print, page 4 has the answers to this worksheet Inductive and Deductive Reasoning - [15 slides] designed for a math class but provides a good overlap of information for this standard Logic and Deductive and Inductive Reasoning - short article explaining the difference and giving examples of each Mission Critical: Induction vs Deduction - explanation followed by statements to evaluate, answers are provided
Evaluate the relevance and quality of evidence given to support or oppose an argument. 3001.5.4	The Art of Argument and Persuasion - lesson plan - understanding the forces that shape their ideas and opinions, and work in reshaping their arguments so that truth and reason are evident. Components of an Argument - outline format of structure of argument with definitions Identifying and Formulating Arguments - article with examples and explanations Persuasive Arguments - lesson plan - Each group member is given an argument and presents it to group members to discuss and generate ideas for persuasion. Students then independently write argument, defending their position. Premise and Conclusion Indicator Words - Words that introduce or appear in an argument premise Self Test on Logic Concepts - quiz with answers
Identify established methods (e.g., scientific, historical) used to distinguish between factual claims and opinions. 3001.5.5
Distinguish between evidence which is directly stated and evidence which is implied. 3001.5.6	Drawing Inferences - how to be a critical reader How are They Selling It? - students read three advertisements and evaluate the type of persuasive writing being employed Inference Notes - Use this diagram to help interpret inferences. Making Inferences and Drawing Conclusions - descriptions of the various ways to aid you in reaching a conclusion Rules of Inference - Lesson discussing the rules of inference.
Identify false statements and explain how they are used in certain kinds of persuasive arguments. 3001.5.7	The Concept of Validity - mini lesson Don't Throw Away That Junk Mail! - lesson plan; students to identify all the techniques used in junk mail to attract and hold the reader's attention that they can think of. Invalid (false premises, true conclusion) - easy to understand explanation Logical Fallacies - article with examples - Fallacies can be either illegitimate arguments or irrelevant points, and are often identified because they lack evidence that supports their claim Some Common Fallacies - brief list of some of the more common fallacies, along with illustrations of them
Explain why common logical fallacies (e.g., the appeal to pity, the personal attack, the false dilemma) do not prove the point being argued. 3001.5.8	The Concept of Validity - mini lesson Don't Throw Away That Junk Mail! - lesson plan; students to identify all the techniques used in junk mail to attract and hold the reader's attention that they can think of. Invalid (false premises, true conclusion) - easy to understand explanation Logical Fallacies - article with examples - Fallacies can be either illegitimate arguments or irrelevant points, and are often identified because they lack evidence that supports their claim Some Common Fallacies - brief list of some of the more common fallacies, along with illustrations of them Top 20 Logical Fallacies - definitions and explanations from The Skeptics' Guide to the Universe
Identify and analyze the stylistic and rhetorical devices that are used to persuade in written and oral communication (e.g., loaded terms, leading questions, false assumptions). 3001.5.9
Explain and evaluate complex relationships in a variety of argumentative texts. 3001.5.10
Identify and analyze similarities and differences in evidence, premises, and conclusions between two or more arguments on the same topic. 3001.5.11
Evaluate the function of verbal techniques such as ambiguity and paradox in constructing an argument. 3001.5.12
State Performance Indicators 5.1 | 5.2 | 5.3 | 5.4 | 5.5 | 5.6 | 5.7 | 5.8 | 5.9
Select the persuasive device (i.e., loaded terms, leading questions, false assumptions) used in an ad or speech. SPI 3001.5.1	Analyzing Political Ads - Students will view current political ads and learn how they make use of various commercial ad appeals. Students will also develop familiarity with basic videography terms. Affluenza: A PBS Program - Lessons such as "Be an Adbuster!" and "What are Advertisers Selling?" are based on Affluenza, a one-hour television special that explores the high social and environmental costs of materialism and over consumption. The lessons can be used without the video. The Art of Argument and Persuasion - lesson plan - understanding the forces that shape their ideas and opinions, and work in reshaping their arguments so that truth and reason are evident. Book Report Alternative: A Character's Letter to the Editor - spur that character to try to persuade the audience of other characters in the novel to take a specific action or change their position on an issue Common Persuasive Techniques - chart with definitions and examples Components of an Argument - outline format of structure of argument with definitions Examples of Persuasive Techniques and Terms - Quia Quiz Helpful Hints for Presenters - [16 slides] many good suggestions can be found in this PowerPoint show by Silvi Marina Identifying and Formulating Arguments - article with examples and explanations Persuasive Arguments - lesson plan - Each group member is given an argument and presents it to group members to discuss and generate ideas for persuasion. Students then independently write argument, defending their position. Persuasive Techniques - key persuasive techniques with explanations Premise and Conclusion Indicator Words - Words that introduce or appear in an argument premise Self Test on Logic Concepts - quiz with answers Text Types - Online game helping learn about the different text types such as persuasion, informative, descriptive, or instructive.
Identify the logical fallacy (i.e., the appeal to pity, the personal attack, the false dilemma) of a given argument. SPI 3001.5.2	The Concept of Validity - mini lesson Don't Throw Away That Junk Mail! - lesson plan; students to identify all the techniques used in junk mail to attract and hold the reader's attention that they can think of. Invalid (false premises, true conclusion) - easy to understand explanation Logical Fallacies - article with examples - Fallacies can be either illegitimate arguments or irrelevant points, and are often identified because they lack evidence that supports their claim Some Common Fallacies - brief list of some of the more common fallacies, along with illustrations of them Top 20 Logical Fallacies - definitions and explanations from The Skeptics' Guide to the Universe
Differentiate between the stated and implied evidence of a given argument. SPI 3001.5.3	Drawing Inferences - how to be a critical reader How are They Selling It? - students read three advertisements and evaluate the type of persuasive writing being employed Inference Notes - Use this diagram to help interpret inferences. Making Inferences and Drawing Conclusions - descriptions of the various ways to aid you in reaching a conclusion Rules of Inference - Lesson discussing the rules of inference.
Determine whether a given argument employ deductive or inductive reasoning. SPI 3001.5.4	Aesop's Fables: Unity - lesson plan Deductive vs Inductive Reasoning - [16 slides] examples of each type of reasoning with opportunities to practice Formal Versus Informal Logic - Deductive Versus Inductive Forms of Reasoning - [13 slides] somewhat advanced, good explanation of each type of reasoning House and Holmes: A Guide to Deductive and Inductive Reasoning - Lesson plan to designed distinguish between deductive and inductive arguments, and to have students construct and analyze deductive arguments and produce and evaluate inductive arguments - links to several attachments provided Inductive and Deductive Reasoning - short explanation followed by a worksheet to print, page 4 has the answers to this worksheet Inductive and Deductive Reasoning - [15 slides] designed for a math class but provides a good overlap of information for this standard Logic and Deductive and Inductive Reasoning - short article explaining the difference and giving examples of each Mission Critical: Induction vs Deduction - explanation followed by statements to evaluate, answers are provided
Draw appropriate inferences from a passage. SPI 3001.5.5	Drawing Inferences - how to be a critical reader How are They Selling It? - students read three advertisements and evaluate the type of persuasive writing being employed Inference Notes - Use this diagram to help interpret inferences. Making Inferences and Drawing Conclusions - descriptions of the various ways to aid you in reaching a conclusion Rules of Inference - Lesson discussing the rules of inference.
Discern an implied main idea from a passage. SPI 3001.5.6
Identify a statement that reveals the writer’s biases, assumptions, or values within a writing sample. SPI 3001.5.7	'Bursting' Stereotypes - Balloons serve as a conduit in this lesson in which students "burst" stereotypes that unfairly label individuals or groups. Censorship in the Classroom - Lesson plan with handouts Evaluating Media for Bias - A checklist when using media in the classroom Holiday Stereotyping - Lesson Plan with handouts Native Americans - EdSITEment Lesson plan Promoting Diversity in the Classroom and School Library through Social Action - lesson plan - students use their findings to promote diversity by creating paired books or text sets that match stereotypical portrayals with balanced and diverse texts. Stereotyping and Bias: The Three Little Pigs - lesson plan - This lesson helps students recognize and understand stereotyping and bias in literature and film by looking at representations of wolves Understanding stereotypes - lesson plan - categorizing things or people is a natural human inclination; however, people often make assumptions about groups of people they don't even know Using Picture Books to Explore Identity, Stereotyping, and Discrimination - Lesson plan with handouts.
Identify the similarities and differences in evidence, premises, and conclusions between two arguments on the same topic. SPI 3001.5.8
Distinguish the strongest or weakest point of an argument within a passage. SPI 3001.5.9	The Art of Argument and Persuasion - lesson plan - understanding the forces that shape their ideas and opinions, and work in reshaping their arguments so that truth and reason are evident. Components of an Argument - outline format of structure of argument with definitions Identifying and Formulating Arguments - article with examples and explanations Persuasive Arguments - lesson plan - Each group member is given an argument and presents it to group members to discuss and generate ideas for persuasion. Students then independently write argument, defending their position. Premise and Conclusion Indicator Words - Words that introduce or appear in an argument premise Self Test on Logic Concepts - quiz with answers
return to the top of the page